People need to question more
Tweet
Justin Covington
You have one hour to decide between your life and your leg.” No, this is not the plot of the next inevitable “Saw” film. It is a very real situation my father faced almost a year ago.
My father had a serious infection in his leg. The doctor at hospital A said that his leg was unsalvageable. My father, being the stubborn man that he is, refused, and went to another hospital.
Hospital B, while not as final as hospital A, told him that there was little hope of him ever walking on it again.
My father was desperate. He called other hospitals, but the convoluted doctor referral system impeded his progress. He was also on a deadline. If the leg didn’t come off soon, then the infection would likely spread to his whole body, leading to his demise.
I visited my father while he was still in hospital B. While I was there, one of my father’s friends came to visit. He decided to take a break from the doctor search and handed me his laptop.
While he and his friend talked, I searched online, until I happened upon an article describing a new procedure to be used as a last resort before leg amputation. Interested, I clicked the link, read the article and gasped.
The patient described in the article was a middle-aged, diabetic, black male who had an infection in his leg. This was a close match to my father. The patient in the story eventually regained mobility after his surgery.
When I told my father, he gave me the biggest hug I can ever remember, and then began making plans to fly to Des Moines, Iowa, to stay in the hospital with the doctor who believed his leg was not a lost cause. I’m not writing this as a way to “LiveJournal” to the masses. I’m doing it to pass on the favor that was done for myself and for my father.
Many lessons can be learned from this story.
Americans in general are not skeptical enough. We don’t ask enough questions, which can allow us to be easily persuaded by those who we believe hold authority in society.
This overconfidence in leaders is also reflected in politics. Despite the system of checks and balances among the three branches at the federal level, we place the most stock in the president. This is in spite of the fact that the president can change very little without the Legislature, and even when policies are implemented, their constitutionality is checked by the Supreme Court.
The lofty, unrealistic expectations placed on prominent members of the community only make it that much worse when such a person doesn’t reach all of their goals.
My father’s ordeal also reinforced the usefulness of the Internet. It took an article being uploaded to the Internet and a Google search to find what two doctors at two different hospitals did not.
This is not a knock on doctors or other medical professionals. To be fair to the doctors at hospital A and hospital B, the procedure used at the hospital in Des Moines is relatively new and complex, and one of the doctors that pioneered the procedure works there. Had it not been for the careful eye of a doctor who saw a spinal cord injury in an X-ray done for sinus problems, I would likely be paralyzed now.
Doctors receive years of training, but no amount of training makes a man infallible.
Asking questions and doing research is critical to many facets of life. While we shouldn’t spend all of our time pondering the repercussions of our actions, we should spend enough that we feel comfortable with the decisions that we make.
After all, it could save you a leg.
Justin Covington is a State News guest columnist and a political science senior. Reach him at coving27@msu.edu.






Commentary
Add your $0.02, go to the comment form or follow the comment feed
hvt
(06/24/09 8:27pm)Report
This is a nice article, Justin. Thanks. I commend your persistence.
I wonder how it would have worked out in a ‘reformed’ health care system. There are certainly plenty of stories from other countries that could suggest shopping for a better answer, as you did here, would not be permitted.
Wanda Bryant
(06/24/09 10:32pm)Report
Not only should people question more but know the right questions to ask. As the health care reform debate begins again, hopefully all interested parties will ask the right questions that will ultimately lead to excellent, accessible health care for all American citizens.
good article
(06/25/09 8:43am)Report
Not only should people question more but know the right questions to ask.
If you dont do your research, you’re just wasting your time. In a democracy (or in a hospital) if you’re not educated on the important issues than you’ll just have to settle. In politics, as in Justin’s fathers case, that often would result in a, uh, less than optimal outcome.
ASK THIS QUESTION
(06/25/09 10:27am)Report
“The Chinese Communist leader openly questioned the amount of USA national debt, now approaching $9,000,000,000,000.00.
“Who has been shown to competently deal with that massive problem?”
Faith
(06/25/09 11:38am)Report
This is a very good article and I have learned something very important here. Something that could save a limb or a life, thank you.
Mr. Anonymous
(06/25/09 1:15pm)Report
I agree. But we live in a country where they scare people by calling them “ungrateful”, “unpatriotic”, “troublemaker”, and worse like “bigot”, “hate speech”, “communist”, “liberal” and even “antisemite”, or “Nazi Hitler’s lover”, for anything you say in disagreement with the government and its policies. O assorted hate mails one receives constantly, including some with sexually insulting images. In a way people are “cowarded” to keep their mouths shut. And I know by experience in many forums. Yes, people should be more outspoken. But few will dare to express unpopular opinions because of the fear of the great barrage of insults they will get. Even a prominent law professor, I will not indentify him, call me “bigot” in an e-mail. This is what this country has become. But I will not be intimidated by these “comments” when I have to express my views.
Interesting...
(06/25/09 2:25pm)Report
Interesting POV MR. A. In the US at large that may hold some water, but at MSU, I for one have seen many people, even liberal people, shouted down as “bigots” or “uneducated/ignorant” for very moderate or even left leaning positions because they’re not far left enough.
Lydia Pettus
(06/26/09 12:14am)Report
Excellent article and very heartfelt. You are a gifted writer,Justin! Looking forward to seeing more!
PRM
(06/29/09 8:34am)Report
I can’t help but wonder if encouraging people to stubbornly deny a grim diagnosis could lead to that patient falling into a worse position due to time wasted. I understand that this worked out in your father’s case, but this seems far from the norm.
Good Point
(06/29/09 12:40pm)Report
In above post. Sometimes time is of essence. It could very well mean life or death. But given a choice asking quetions, and getting informed answers is the way to go.
John Connor
(06/29/09 6:40pm)Report
I found this article to be interesting and I have enjoyed the blogs too. I really like what I have read today. I am brand new, what a great discovery that this paper happens to be. Great job MSU and students.
g. busey
(06/30/09 2:38pm)Report
you suck at writing
Really ^^^^????
(07/01/09 12:15pm)Report
So you think so. Well not everyone has the brillant mind that others are may be blessed with. Call it a gift. But gifts from the heart are pretty good to, don’t you think? Or wait I know there are more nerve endings in the head…being cute…so laugh. My how can you be so young and so bright??
AceKlub
(07/01/09 10:37pm)Report
Great article and very moving! Keep up the good work.