Saturday, March 20, 2010 | Since 1909 | East Lansing, MI Advertise | Classifieds | Puzzles | Employment | Contact Us
Feed:
Follow us on:
Mostly Cloudy, 39° F | 4° C
7 day forecast

Second from left, East Lansing resident Hans Larsen argues his position Wednesday evening at the ASMSU sponsored panel discussion for the City Council candidates. From left, Mayor Vic Loomis, Larsen, Councilmember Kevin Beard and MSU professor Phil Bellfy are the four candidates running for the two open East Lansing City Council positions.


Article Tools:

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Digg this
  • Add to del.icio.us
  • Blogger
  • Comment feed
  • Print

Candidates present views at MSU Union during student-led question and answer session

By Kate Jacobson (Last updated: 10/29/09 12:15am)

Editor’s note: This is the final edition in a series of articles profiling the candidates for the two open City Council seats in the Nov. 3 election.

The Union became a site of heated debate and tension Wednesday as the four candidates for East Lansing City Council’s two open seats gathered to respond to students’ questions and insert jabs at one another’s views.

The ASMSU-sponsored forum was the candidates’ first joint appearance to debate their stances on local issues The incumbents, Mayor Vic Loomis and Councilmember Kevin Beard, are vying against the challengers, local activist Hans Larsen and MSU professor Phil Bellfy, for the two open seats on the East Lansing City Council.

The forum, a structured question and answer session, was meant to give permanent residents and students a chance to hear the issues from each candidate’s point of view.

ASMSU is MSU’s undergraduate student government.

With about 20 people in attendance, the candidates discussed hot-button issues affecting both students and permanent residents. Emily Serkaian, the community liaison for ASMSU, said the idea behind the forum was created two years ago by former ASMSU Community Liaison and current Student Assembly Chairperson Kyle Dysarz, and because of the positive response, Serkaian decided to host again.

“There really haven’t been any other formal organizational efforts (to put on a forum) so it was nice to have this,” Serkaian said.

The questions

The night featured some heated topics, including questions regarding the City Center II project and candidates’ involvement with MSU. City Center II is a development project slated for the area between the corners of Abbot Road and Grand River and Evergreen avenues.

Many of the candidates accused the others of misrepresenting facts and jabbed at their positions.

ASMSU members and audience members drafted questions for the event. ASMSU Academic Assembly Chairperson Kristy Currier submitted a question regarding the Medical Amnesty Bill recently passed in the Michigan Senate, which would prevent legal action against a minor who seeks medical help for overconsumption of alcohol.

All four candidates supported the bill, although Bellfy said he was not familiar with it.

Loomis said he applauded ASMSU’s efforts to get the bill passed. He said it was another example of the working relationship between MSU and the City Council.

Larsen said although he supported the bill, it was sad the bill was needed in the first place. He said it was up to the prosecuting attorney in each case whether or not to prosecute someone for trying to help another person in medical need if they’re an intoxicated minor.

In his rebuttal, Loomis pointed out there were no prosecuting attorneys for the city of East Lansing, to which Larsen said Loomis was incorrect.

Beard also supported the bill, saying it was important not to risk student safety.

“We lose young people every year … because of overconsumption and alcohol poisoning,” he said. “I think this is a tool which we can use … to encourage the Good Samaritan to do the right thing.”

The candidates’ involvement leading up to the election also was addressed. An MSU student asked how each candidate engaged students.

Larsen said his goal in the campaign is to enlighten residents and students about city officials’ wrongdoings.

“My primary focus of this campaign is to expose the massive, reckless waste and squandering of taxpayer dollars to the detriment of the taxpayers, all to bail out a financially insolvent developer,” Larsen said, referring to City Center II.

Loomis and Beard listed off their involvement in student groups, as well as awards and endorsements they had received.

Bellfy, who is a professor at MSU, mentioned his direct relationship with students on a daily basis, as well as his involvement as an adviser to on-campus student groups.

Public response

Serkaian said she thought the dialogue was successful. She said ASMSU wanted to give students access to the candidates, and she hopes to continue panel discussions for future elections.

“There were some good issues discussed,” she said.

Graduate student Connie Cheng, who attended the panel, said seeing the candidates in person and getting to know who they were helped her educate herself about the candidates and important East Lansing issues.

“I like to hear this kind of democracy process because I come originally from China, and I am learning democracy,” she said.

Originally Published: 10/28/09 11:59pm




PHOTOS OF THE WEEK:More reprints »
Photo courtesy of Wharton Center /

Performers in the traveling professional group Nrityagram perform their tradItional Indian dances.

Powered by reprints.statenews.com.


Commentary:


Daniel J.

10/29/09 3:58pm

Just so everyone knows, you aren’t in East Lansing jurisdiction until you go north of Grand River Ave. The very large rural campusis solely under the local legislative authority of the MSU Board of Trustees, not the East Lansing City Council.

Will Lansing City Council candidates also debate in the MSU Union?

Kevin Beard

10/29/09 8:53pm

Dear Daniel J. – Residents on the campus of Michigan State University are within the corporate boundaries of the City of East Lansing and if registered to vote here are eligible to cast a ballot in the election on November 3, 2009. The State of Michigan allows for the MSU Board of Trustees to act as the legislative body for the campus property and control their own affairs. But in all other respects the students are citizens and voters of East Lansing.

Daniel J.

10/30/09 11:11am

If the Clerk of East Lansing is allowing those with driver’s licenses addressed for dorms and university housing on campus to obtain EL voter registration, then I must inform you s/he is making a mistake by registering you for East Lansing.

Furthermore, if the campus were incorporated within the City of East Lansing, that could constitute a violation of the Michigan statutes that call for the political autonomy of our public universities.

If MSU were part of the corporate body of East Lansing, there would be no Michigan State Police (DPPS) it would only be East Lansing PD.

...

View full comment »

Phil Bellfy

10/31/09 1:19pm

Daniel J. —I’m sorry to disagree, but it is perfectly legal for residents on campus (students) to register and vote in East Lansing. Accepting your argument would essentially mean that all students residing in the dorms would be dis-enfranchised. I know many people within the city power structure would be happier if your “opinion” was actual law, but it is not.

Students —I encourage you to vote on Tuesday.

...

View full comment »

Hans Larsen, IV

11/01/09 8:53pm

QUESTION. How many MSU students actually showed up to the debate?

ANSWER: 5 students

The whole thing was a complete sham, which was poorly attended, not advertised, and not televised. The incumbents postponed the debate for several weeks, and they made sure that the students voices would NOT be heard.

A recording of the debate can be found on publicresponse.com

Hans Larsen, IV

Student

11/02/09 5:23pm

Hans,

There were at the very bare minimum 12 students at the forum.

Furthermore,

Maybe the reason why not many students showed up was because no one really cares who is on the EL city council, though for their sakes, I hope you don’t get elected, because sure enough if you are elected you will not be representing the students. You will have your head to far up City Center II to see the issues that students actually care about. You kind of remind me of people like Ron Paul and Ralph Nader who run for President, just want to get your face out there, harp on one issue, and eventually get crushed at the polls. I would stick to your day job. Do you actually have one?

student

11/02/09 5:29pm

Furthermore Hans,

How can you say it was postponed by the incumbents? I thought ASMSU did an excellent job of putting on the forum, it was near the election and had all 4 candidates present. Weren’t you the one I overheard complaining to that moderator girl that you didn’t want to sit next to the incumbents at the debate? Hmmm, and you want to be on city council? I guess if you were elected you would have a little high-chair in the corner and someone could make you a hat that said “Hi, I’m newly elected councilchild Larsen, don’t mind me, I can’t sit at the grownup table until I myself grow up.”

Ann Larsen

11/02/09 11:04pm

Let’s face it. This “debate”, at a minimum, should have been at least one of the local public television stations- which have been designated and intended for just such “events”. What a joke. And it was deliberately delayed. Additionally, the only feed I could, as a member of the general public, could obtain was poor audio- that actually demonstrated the command Hans Larsen had over the actual facts and matter and bigger picture.

...

View full comment »