Saturday, November 21, 2009 | Since 1909 | East Lansing, MI Advertise | Classifieds | Puzzles | Employment | Contact Us
Feed:
Follow us on:
Clear, 39° F | 4° C
7 day forecast

Article Tools:

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Digg this
  • Add to del.icio.us
  • Blogger
  • Comment feed
  • Print

'Fourth Kind' lacks focus, removes viewer from story

By Carter Moulton (Last updated: 10/29/09 12:10am)

Close encounter of the first kind: sighting of a UFO.

Close encounter of the second kind: physical evidence.

Close encounter of the third kind: contact with extraterrestrial life.

Close encounter of the fourth kind: frustratingly bad execution, acting and makeup.

“The Fourth Kind” begins with actress Milla Jovovich (of the “Resident Evil” series) walking toward the camera in a morning-lit forest. She looks at the camera and tells the audience she is portraying psychologist Abigail Tyler throughout the film, which is based on facts. She then tells viewers archived footage and audio of Tyler’s “rare case studies” are used throughout the film and, to protect certain individuals, the names have been changed.

Then we get a glimpse of the “real footage.” Fail. The “real” Tyler looks more like an extraterrestrial than a human being. With makeup splotched over her pale-as-crusted-Elmer’s-glue skin, the actress who plays the “real” Tyler is annoying to listen to, on the edge of tears with her every whimpered word.

The story takes place in Nome, Alaska, and revolves around Tyler and the mysterious death of her husband. Now the sole parent of two children, Tyler continues work, where she begins to hear strange accounts of an “owl-like figure” perching over patients in their sleep.

The “real” footage during Tyler’s meetings with patients is more well done, but director and writer Olatunde Osunsanmi chooses to split the screen in half — sometimes in quarters — to show the “real” footage and the re-enactments at the same time. For instance, we see the “real” footage of a patient convulsing under hypnosis on the left half of the screen and the actor re-enacting the patient on the right. This technique reminds us the re-enactment is just that: acting.

Jovovich does an admirable job as the re-enacted Tyler, but the other acting in the film is unintentionally funny. Will Patton from “Remember the Titans” plays the sheriff of Nome, and his character redefines the meaning of stupidity by ignoring everyone around him and randomly shouting irrelevant orders across rooms.

The story really gets going with Egyptian gods, dead languages, owls, a theme of Christianity (random references to “3:33”) and alien abductions all trying to meld into one cohesive story. And this is supposed to be true?

The only shred of truth about the film is that there have been a large number of missing persons in Nome since 1960. More than 20 people have gone missing during this time period, according to the FBI. That’s about one and a half people per year, which I wouldn’t consider a large amount.

Osunsanmi’s execution simply doesn’t match his ambition, and although I see the goal of making the audience wonder what is real, the “real” footage isn’t convincing enough. There’s not enough focus in Osunsanmi’s story and not enough satisfaction in the “scares” he provides; there’s too much of the “real” Tyler sniveling over the soundtrack. Do yourself a favor, stop counting at “Close Encounters of the Third Kind” and watch Steven Spielberg’s classic from 1977.

Watch the official trailer for ‘The Fourth Kind’ on YouTube

Originally Published: 10/28/09 8:58pm




PHOTOS OF THE WEEK:More reprints »
Sean Cook / The State News

Gov. Jennifer Granholm speaks to a crowd about the Michigan Promise Scholarship during a rally Wednesday morning outside the Administration Building. Granholm is touring colleges in Michigan to discuss the scholarship.

Powered by reprints.statenews.com.


Commentary:

darwin

10/29/09 1:06pm

i disagree. i actually really liked the fourth kind and thought that it was excellent film technique. the split screen made it more real for me.

and i thought all the actors did a great job reenacting the real footages.

it was scary for sure. definitely worth watching.

Casey

10/29/09 6:58pm

Say what you will, but I just saw this last weekend at my university and it was INSANELY freaky for me and the rest of my friends that went. Maybe the reenacting footage is not great, but you have to admit that the other footage was damn scary. I guess got to disagree as well, this film will I think keep you on the edge of your seeat – and after seeing Paranormal Activity – it kicks the crap out of it.

yoyoyoitsjdo

10/30/09 2:54am

I just watched this at my university… and the reviewer hit it on the mark. We were laughing through half the movie because of the unintentionally funny acting. And the “real” Abigail Tyler looks more like an alien than the aliens do. AND the alien “voices” are straight out of a very, very bad horror film from the 90s.

ceriallover

10/30/09 7:50pm

what! I thought it was really witty and scary.

yeah wayyyy better than paranormal cuz The fourth kind actually has a great plot.

the ending facts were very crazy too. got me thinking.