Health services move to neighborhoods good idea
Tweet
In these trying economic times, we’ve all been forced to cut costs, but it’s not always so easy. For an organization as large as MSU, balancing a budget requires slightly more unorthodox and creative strategies.
Proposals and prognostications on how MSU will continue to survive into the next decade have abounded, with MSU suggesting cutting costs in the most unexpected of places.
One such proposal by the administration was to move the student health services from Olin Health Center to the MSU Clinical Center on Service Road. But when this information was leaked, it caused no small stir among the MSU community.
Many students objected to this change, asking how moving student health services farther away to a more remote location improved students’ overall welfare and convenience. We even voiced our outright objection to the plan in an editorial published last month.
One possibility that did not come up in the recent debate, however, was the idea of moving Olin’s services to MSU’s six dorm “neighborhoods” instead of the MSU Clinical Center. This information came to light when last week The State News Editorial Board sat down with MSU president Lou Anna K. Simon and MSU spokesman Terry Denbow.
The basic idea is that Olin’s services would be spread out and split among the six neighborhoods on campus, which all would provide general care to students. In the case of an emergency, these small clinics would provide transportation to other places such as Lansing Urgent Care or Sparrow Hospital. The overall idea would be to make student health services more convenient for students by bringing health care to them — not the other way around.
We can’t find much wrong with this idea, at least in how it was described to us. Each neighborhood clinic would be open to every MSU student, including those living off campus. When student health services are closer to the students, the students are much more likely to take advantage of them, which couldn’t help but result in the improved health of the student body.
Our one concern would be the obvious fact that each of these smaller centers would not be as well-equipped as the large central center that exists now at Olin.
One way to get around this would be to have certain “specializations” at different neighborhood centers. Each center would provide general care, but perhaps the Brody clinic could specialize in blood work, or the Red Cedar clinic in sexually transmitted infections. A student might have to go a little farther to get something they need, but likely it wouldn’t be too much of an inconvenience.
Obviously, there still are plenty of unknowns about this plan. Primarily, it’s still unclear to us how making six medical clinics instead of one would effectively cut costs for the university. If this is a real possibility for students, the administration needs to explain its reasoning and seek feedback on this in a responsible way.
If the university really sees a chance to save money and improve health services for students, then this idea is a win-win. But it’s up to the administration to prove that they’re serious about this, and that this idea, while well-intentioned, isn’t just another pipe-dream conjured up to temporarily appease students.






Commentary
Add your $0.02, go to the comment form or follow the comment feed
Kristin
(11/10/09 9:30am)Report
Gee, can’t foresee any problems with that…
“You’ll need to get an x-ray (located on the north end of campus), bloodwork (located on the west end of campus), and pick up this prescription (located on the east end of campus). Oh, you wanted to get a flu shot, too? No problem… Go to the immunization clinic on the south end of campus.”
MaximumBob
(11/10/09 10:15am)Report
How would the separation, duplication and elimination of specific treatment tools benefit the student population?
Six health centers means six opportunities to duplicate facilities, equipment and staff. You know that’s not gonna happen. Instead, existing resources would be split among these six health centers. All this would do is result in increased overhead and variable costs.
If an ambulatory, non-emergency case cannot find their way to Olin, they probably aren’t in need of these services. If they are in critical need, a single health center will be able to properly staff and and administer emergency services.
concerned
(11/10/09 3:58pm)Report
This is a pipedream. Other big ten universities do this, so a HT bigwig thinks it would be cool to jump on board. Perhaps they don’t have the budget problems we do. Leave the health center alone and start looking how it’s run instead of where to move it.
Go Green!
(11/10/09 8:12pm)Report
Why is it that the admin is pushing to “realign” health care services now, but in a few years, push to offer 5 sets of duplicate services to students? Not just health care, but other services as well…
And along the same lines, what is going to happen to the health care on campus in the time between now and when the neighborhood concept is introduced? Why can’t the administration hold off on moving Olin to the Clinical Center until the neighborhood concept is implemented? Instead of 2 major moves, let’s just have 1…
shy
(11/11/09 10:41am)Report
How would privacy be effected? At Olin you go into one building and have a number of different services. I don’t want anyone seeing me walk into the clinic that treats sexually transmitted diseases.
Lauren K
(11/11/09 3:58pm)Report
Wouldn’t that create the need to more facilities ($$$), more doctors/nurses/receptionists ($$$), and what ‘Kristin’ above said?? Olin is a joke anyways, they said I had pneumonia, strep throat, and the flu before sending me to the hospital because they had me on the wrong medication.