Sunday February 12, 2012 | Since 1909 | East Lansing, MI Advertise | Classifieds | Puzzles | Employment | Contact Us | Subscriptions
Feed:
Follow us on:
Clear, 21° F | -6° C
7 day forecast

MSU should allow students to attend jury duty

Originally Published: 02/10/10 7:09pm Modified: 02/10/10 7:12pm 8 comments

Go to class and break the law, or skip class and risk failing? That’s the worry of some students who are summoned for jury duty during the semester.

According to current MSU College of Law attendance policies, a student cannot miss more than two weeks of class, regardless of the excuse, including a legal obligation such as jury duty. So if a student was summoned for jury duty and the court case lasted more than two weeks, that student would not receive credit for an entire semester of work.

Last week, Rep. Mark Meadows, D-East Lansing, introduced a revised bill in the Michigan Legislature that would allow college students to postpone jury duty until after the school year. The amendment would be an addition to a bill that already allows high school students the same right.

The bill would give “a full-time student enrolled in and attending a college, community college, or university” the ability to “postpone the person’s term of service until the end of the school year.” Currently, citizens can delay their jury duty and reschedule within a 30-day period. Although it’s not a bad idea, it might be easier and quicker for universities to implement such policies, rather than the state Legislature.

The MSU College of Law is a separate entity from MSU and follows guidelines from the American Bar Association. MSU does not have a universal attendance policy. Because MSU lacks a standard policy, many students are left unaware of how jury duty will affect their class standing. Currently, attendance policies are at the professors’ discretion — so a professor can allow a student miss every class, or none.

Students should not have to worry whether their academic standing is in jeopardy for fulfilling a civic duty. Sitting on a jury shouldn’t be something for which students are punished. The university has a policy excusing employees on days they have to serve jury duty, so why not students?

When a criminal goes to trial, he or she is supposed to be judged by a jury of their peers. As students, a major section of our peers could be taken away if students are excused from filling their roles as jurors.

It should be the university’s responsibility to come up with a policy that includes students serving jury duty. In the resulting attendance policy, there should be a clause excusing students who are fulfilling their duty as citizens.

Meadows’ attempt is commendable, but he and the state Legislature shouldn’t be the ones responsible for excusing students from a legal obligation. MSU should take the initiative and not force the Legislature to solve the problem.

Leaving the policy changes to the universities in the state would offer several advantages over the state government. The changes could be implemented much more swiftly than waiting for any bills to be passed and each university could tailor the policies to fit its student body. Having the universities take their own approach toward jury duty also would allow more flexibility in changing the rules regarding students missing classes to abide by the law.

Being summoned for jury duty is a commitment that every citizen is responsible to fulfill. Students shouldn’t have to break the law just to pass a class.


Article Tools:
Short URL:
http://www.statenews.com/r/5ca95be5


FEATURED CLASSIFIEDS: More classifieds »

In Employment:

In Services:


Powered by Disqus

PHOTOS OF THE WEEK:More reprints »
  • Fireworks

    A firework display shimmers and shines above Cooley Law School Stadium Sunday night after the Lansing ...

  • 44119_mdh_fea_florence2_062611f.jpg

    Florence Welch, lead singer of London-based indie group Florence and the Machine, throws up a sign of ...

  • Pile of bricks

    As deconstruction of the MSC smokestack continues, bricks pile up at the foot of the once iconic MSU ...

  • Archeology

    Paige Triezenberg, a global and area studies senior, uses a small trowel to clear dirt around an animal ...

  • Carillon

    Bournville, England resident Trevor Workman plays the carillon for the first Muelder Summer Carillon ...

Available for purchase today at State News Reprints.


EVENT CALENDAR More Events »

Commentary

Add your $0.02, go to the comment form or follow the comment feed

In My Opion
(02/10/10 7:32pm)
Report
Comment

When you get a letter for jury duty there is a number you can call and I myself wasn’t able to do jury duty, I was scheuled to a vaction at the time. I called and talked with someone. I can’t remember if I had to write a letter as well and send it back with my jury duty request, stating the reason that I could not serve on jury duty at the time. I also took down the name of the person that I spoke with. I would have to believe that if a full time student were to state that they were in school full time and that jury duty would impose on their studies that they would definately be excused. I wish some sort of information was given here to show students exactly what they need to do if this situation should arise.


Carla
(02/10/10 8:53pm)
Report
Comment

I’ve been called for jury duty 3 times since I’ve been an MSU student and it’s never been a problem. Although there is not a law excusing/postponing college students from jury duty, one of the options on the form says, “full time student” It has never been a problem, and I never had to “break the law.”

There is no reason why a student should miss two weeks of class, that’s ridiculous. Taking the student population out of the jury duty pool, does make sense, because I’m paying thousands of dollars to be here at MSU. Unlike a person with a job, who GETS paid to do their job, and can safely miss two weeks of work legally. This whole article lacks information.


Bleed Green
(02/11/10 8:03am)
Report
Comment

I think it makes perfect sense for the legislature to change the law so full-time students can POSTPONE their jury duty to a time when they’re out of school. Having MSU make a policy that excuses a student for the length of a trial (2 weeks or whatever length) doesn’t matter if the student is then COMPLETELY LOST coming back for the semester.This way, students get a chance to serve and perform their civic duty, and ALSO have the opportunity to pass their classes (if, say, the trial goes for an extended period). What’s the problem here?


it is not hard.....
(02/11/10 9:33am)
Report
Comment

to get out of jury duty. Show up in ripped up jeans, a stained and dirty t shirt. I can continue, but you all get the idea.


really?
(02/11/10 10:32am)
Report
Comment

students can barely make it to class, let alone do their civic duty…this article is worthless, much like the debate.


The Question of What IF?
(02/11/10 12:01pm)
Report
Comment

Pretend it is too much stress to make a decision whether someone is guilty or not. Be a What If-fer For example, you could say: Well ‘what if’ I say they are guilty and they are not? How could I ever live with myself? But on the other hand ‘what if’ they were guilty and I set them free, how could I ever live with myself? GET THE ‘what if’ idea, it works everytime:)


is
(02/11/10 4:42pm)
Report
Comment

i got called for jury duty and told them i was full-time student. end of story


Evader
(02/15/10 3:20pm)
Report
Comment

I’ve never heard of the courts summoning anyone to jury duty via CERTIFIED MAIL. If you don’t return the summon, no one can prove you received it. And the courts are going to waste their time tracking someone down who really doesn’t want to cooperate. Bottome line- if you don’t want to be a juror then don’t return the summon.