Sunday February 12, 2012 | Since 1909 | East Lansing, MI Advertise | Classifieds | Puzzles | Employment | Contact Us | Subscriptions
Feed:
Follow us on:
Clear, 20° F | -7° C
7 day forecast

Report important, but not the be-all, end-all

Originally Published: 09/02/10 8:28pm Modified: 09/02/10 8:28pm 5 comments

In a recent college ranking study published by U.S. News & World Report, MSU was ranked last out of all the colleges currently in the Big Ten Conference. When it’s phrased that way, it sounds pretty awful, and kind of demeaning. But in most cases, the MSU experience is not one that can be captured by a number.

This study is nationally regarded as a credible, reliable college ranking source. So, the numbers should not be completely disregarded. Prospective students could look at the study and base some of their college goals and choices upon it. A high rank on this list initially could draw competitive students from around the country and the globe to any college or university, simply because it is one of the “best.” It gives the highly ranked institutions an edge of sorts, something they can brag about during their orientations.

However, choosing a path of higher education is not a decision that should be made simply by facts and figures. It’s a hugely personal choice, and what people find appealing when picking out a college or university varies greatly.

Financial situations, choice of major, athletic interest, individual preference and other factors that can’t necessarily be encompassed by an overall ranking are taken into consideration as well. Also, colleges can be different in reality than they are in facts and figures. Depending on taste, the very atmosphere of a university can be a turn-off. Likewise, it could convince a student he or she has found the perfect fit. A ranking conveys a number, but can miss other tangible factors.

Additionally, it’s important for anyone considering a college education to note that personal success cannot be gauged by any given institution’s success. One doesn’t have to go to Harvard or another top ranked school to get what they want out of life and to make his or her future the best it possibly can be. It might be advantageous to attend those schools, but it’s not the final word.

MSU students should not feel their education is worth less because it’s last in the Big Ten Conference according to the U.S. News & World Report. Future leaders in any given career field could be walking along the banks of the Red Cedar River right now.

The university will continue going about its daily business. It’s not as if they will go through massive curriculum overhauls because of the score it received in a report. Any institution has issues that could be fixed or improved in some way, but it wouldn’t be practical to blindly imitate the schools that the U.S. News & World Report considers the best. MSU’s uniqueness adds to its appeal as a university and rushing headlong into changes would not be beneficial to anyone in particular.

In the end, what a school means to a student cannot be solely based on what rank it acquired in a nationally accredited study. The value of an education and overall college experience is very individualized. Regardless of the ranking, there are plenty of people who will always consider MSU their No. 1 college in the U.S.


Article Tools:
Short URL:
http://www.statenews.com/r/350a1b98


FEATURED CLASSIFIEDS: More classifieds »

In Employment:

In Services:


Powered by Disqus

PHOTOS OF THE WEEK:More reprints »
  • Fireworks

    A firework display shimmers and shines above Cooley Law School Stadium Sunday night after the Lansing ...

  • 44119_mdh_fea_florence2_062611f.jpg

    Florence Welch, lead singer of London-based indie group Florence and the Machine, throws up a sign of ...

  • Pile of bricks

    As deconstruction of the MSC smokestack continues, bricks pile up at the foot of the once iconic MSU ...

  • Archeology

    Paige Triezenberg, a global and area studies senior, uses a small trowel to clear dirt around an animal ...

  • Carillon

    Bournville, England resident Trevor Workman plays the carillon for the first Muelder Summer Carillon ...

Available for purchase today at State News Reprints.


EVENT CALENDAR More Events »

Commentary

Add your $0.02, go to the comment form or follow the comment feed

KJ Green
(09/03/10 5:51pm)
Report
Comment

There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics. (Attribution varies)

I’m not suggesting the US News Annual College Ranking is a fabrication. However, the assertion that there is more to a college choice than what the rankings present is absolutely true. It is even more true when you look at the basis for the US News rankings.

While there are a number of objective criteria that go into the rankings, there is a major component of the ranking that is subjective. Depending on the type of school, 22.5 to 25 percent of the ranking is based on academic reputation. This includes peer assessment surveys and high school counselor ratings. There is no way that many, if any, survey respondents can provide meaningful assessment based on present-day reality. Rather, they likely respond based on what they think the quality of each school is. Thus, there is not much movement in the top-ranked schools largely because of a self-perpetuating perception of the quality of a school.

There is also a trend emerging where many schools are refusing to respond to the survey. Less than 50 percent of college officials responded to the latest survey. At what point does the lack of respondents make the value of the survey results useless?

There is one small component of the US News methodology that bears mentioning. Although it is only five percent of the ranking weight, US News considers proportion of alumni giving (annual support) as a factor. Many of the top-ranked schools have alumni support that is far in excess of that of MSU. If people do truly consider MSU as their No. 1 college in the U.S., hopefully they will also support it financially when they have the means to do so.

I strongly agree with the premise the writer asserts that there is more to a college selection than what US News surveys. And MSU offers many of these extra intangibles. However, I would further suggest that part of MSU’s current ranking does not consider recent initiatives and successes. MSU, and its alumni, need to continue to ensure that those outside the MSU community are aware of the great things we are and we do.


agreed
(09/03/10 9:44pm)
Report
Comment

to kj: agreed, my thoughts exactly.


MTH 1825
(09/05/10 9:44am)
Report
Comment

Any major research university that even considers offering a MATH 1825 course deserves dead last ranking.


Perception is reality
(09/05/10 12:47pm)
Report
Comment

KJ Green wrote: While there are a number of objective criteria that go into the rankings, there is a major component of the ranking that is subjective. Yeah, tell that to the Cedar Village rioters! As an alumni living in the Southeast, I still get “party school” jabs and insults whenever MSU makes the news here for football or basketball. I’m still pissed at the Village Idiots who forever changed public perception on what used to be seen an excellent school. And that’s why my “alumni giving” has gone to zero.


See also...
(09/06/10 5:27am)
Report
Comment

…the YAF nonsense. I no longer get ‘party school’, I now get ‘center of hate’.

Imagine the number of decent students turned away by that alone.