Saturday, November 7, 2009 | Since 1909 | East Lansing, MI Advertise | Classifieds | Puzzles | Employment | Contact Us
Feed:
Follow us on:
Clear, 57° F | 14° C
7 day forecast

Dragon Ball Z not fit for big screen

By: Jahshua Smith Posted: 07/07/08 9:37pm

Not too many people were as into “Dragon Ball Z” as me during the latter part of high school. My first introductions to the world of anime, along with “Pokémon”, was courtesy of Akira Toriyama’s creation.

Naturally, for a soap opera and wrestling enthusiast, a show like “DBZ” that’s full of cliffhangers and story arcs, would have its appeal because of the similar tone and drama. Also, as a cartoon it also allowed larger than life story lines and plot devices that gave it the same superhero feel reminiscent of vintage series like “Mighty Morphin Power Rangers” and “Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.”

That’s exactly why I cringed when I found out that a big screen adaptation of the series’ predecessor, “Dragon Ball,” was planning to hit screens in 2009.

For starters, the live action aspect of the film makes for an outlandishly bad idea.

The cartoon universe is filled with characters that would come off as goofy in a non-animated film. One character, Piccolo, is a protagonist of a fictional race that at best vaguely resembles a reptile.

We know how this story ends. Remember how the Goombas from “Super Mario Brothers” looked on cinema? For that matter, imagine how “The Simpsons” would look if their movie was live action and not CGI (computer graphics imaging). It’d be too silly to take seriously.

The ludicrousness of such an idea is what effectively kills a franchise like “Dragon Ball Z’s” marketability, despite the fact that several animated films of “DBZ” have sold well as straight-to-video entities — any one of which could serve as a basis for a big screen adaptation with state-of-the-art animation.

Instead we’re likely to get another cartoon-to-3D dud like “Speed Racer” or “Double Dragon.”

The plot thus far, based on the script floating around the Internet, seems uninspired. The casting also seems nonsensical, with many characters only matching their cartoon counterpart by ethnicity and nothing more.

The inclusion of things like guns which never played a role in the original cartoon just goes to show a lack of research and devotion to the franchise— a cardinal sin for such a movie.

Hollywood needs to realize quickly that action movies can derive from cartoons and such, be extravagant, and still go over well with fans. “Dragon Ball Z” will be nothing more than a dud that neither casual moviegoers or hard-core fans will find much entertainment value in.

Jump to comments

Entertainment Blog

The features desk discusses everything from weekend happenings to the latest movies, music and celebrity gossip.

Check out the Entertainment Podcast for more from the features desk.

Subscribe.

Commentary:

vegita

07/07/08 11:53pm

Lets hope your wrong, but youve probably nailed it.

dbzsuperfan

07/08/08 8:13pm

Not sure weather or not to laugh or to cry at the idea of guns being introduced into a cheap mimic of what dbz is all about… whoever is producing such a retarded idea should be stripped naked and left hanging upside down as a pinjata for Japanese school kids. I agree with Vegita on this one. hope its worth the time and money, but one can only hope the true essence of a classic can be re-achieved.

charlie

07/09/08 12:06am

i too agree with vegita but i also think that many fans will go see it and ‘might’ find it rather disapointing. example: the hulk04,speed racer

Echo

07/13/08 4:25pm

Same for me for the most part. I’m a hardcore fan but will probably pay to see it if the previews impress me. If they don’t (though they normally do) I’ll just wait until I can rent it (which shouldn’t take long if it turns out that bad). However, as a fan and as someone who has seen some things done very well despite entire missing chapters (like LOTR) I’m holding out some hope for this, I really am.

ashamed

07/16/08 10:26am

I think all the movie needs is a better director. If you take into account movies like The Matrix, Spiderman, Transformers, Iron Man, The Hulk. DBZ is a very possible movie to make. All it takes is the right people to make the world of DBZ seem real. If the people used in the movies I mentioned earlyer are used, DBZ could be a realy great movie.

PHOTOS OF THE WEEK:More reprints »
Josh Radtke / The State News

Senior linebacker Brandon Denson holds up the Paul Bunyan Trophy after the Spartans defeated Michigan in overtime 26-20 Saturday afternoon at Spartan Stadium.

Powered by reprints.statenews.com.